Home Page › Forums › Fiction Writing › Critiques › Novel Critique Requests › Y’ALLL!!!!! I started it…and I love this already!!! <3 Any thoughts? :D
- This topic has 37 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 3 years, 4 months ago by
Light.
-
AuthorPosts
-
November 30, 2022 at 5:57 pm #122747
@freedomwriter76
I love all the brothers (not the step brothers) soooo much!
That was really good! Can’t wait to read more ?
Also, she’s not there actual mom is she… I was going to ask at the beginning if they were adopted.
"Past or future... let them be."
November 30, 2022 at 5:59 pm #122748@freedomwriter76
That’s a good part too. I did say it was ONE of my favorites…
I just like blowing stuff up. *Face palm* XD
But the one to one conversations are priceless!
Also, in that last one, I love the mildly creepy way you described Felix. *Shudder* đ
Hot Milk+Brown Sugar+Vanilla+Ginger+Cinnamon=All the comfort this world can offer.
November 30, 2022 at 6:58 pm #122762@freedomwriter76
AHHHH!!!! GIRLLLL!!!! THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!!!! â¤ď¸?â¤ď¸
YOU’RE SOOO WELCOME!!! đ đ
Lol, thatâs great!!! XD
Yeah!! XD
I KNOW, RIGHT!?!?!? â¤ď¸â¤ď¸â¤ď¸â¤ď¸
YES!!!! <3 <3
Lol, yes, Frida, look out. XD
Yes. We’re coming for you XD Frida…
Lol, it does!!!! xD xD xD
Leo and Brothers, trademark pending.
XDXDXDXD
Lol Girl, you are so funny XD!
Aww, thank you!!!! (The one where theyâre kids and teens, right? =D) Dialogue is always fun for me, and itâs been a lot of practice to get to where it is nowâŚXD
You’re welcome!! (Yep, that’s the one! đ Yeah, I can tell you’ve had lots of practice :)!
Aghh!!! Me too! XD It started in the Character Castle, and I was like: âWell, Iâm keeping it now!!!â XD
Yes!! It’s so sweet, and helps to give them a deeper relationship :). I’m glad you did!
Thatâs epic!!! I quote Marvel all the timeâŚbut then my family is normally just confused, esp. my sisterâŚlol. XDXDXDXD
Lol! That sounds like me and my family XD.
Aww, girl, thank you!!! â¤ď¸â¤ď¸â¤ď¸ And donât worry, Iâm working on writing more right now. ?
You’re so welcome!! yay!! Oh, is Leon Wagner…Leon? As in, Riker’s enemy turned best friend?
#HugRikerSquad
December 1, 2022 at 8:38 am #122773@freedomwriter76
I love this! I like how the brothers interact with each other, it’s so much fun to read! And good job keeping them distinct with personalities and everything, that’s hard when you have a lot of characters! Keep it up, I want to read more!
Be brave. Be strong. Be bold.
-Christopher BlakewellDecember 1, 2022 at 9:21 am #122775Anonymous
- Rank: Chosen One
- Total Posts: 8156
I love all the brothers (not the step brothers) soooo much!
So happy you do!!! Oh yeah, you can dislike Adolphus and Dietrich as much as you want. XD
That was really good! Canât wait to read more ?
Thank you!!! And I’m halfway done with Chapter 5, so it shouldn’t be much longer!!! đ
Also, sheâs not there actual mom is she⌠I was going to ask at the beginning if they were adopted.
Isn’t that a spoiler…? XD But they are not adopted, and she’s not their actual mom…you’ll see. đ I like to keep y’all asking questions. XDXDXD
Thatâs a good part too. I did say it was ONE of my favoritesâŚ
I just like blowing stuff up. *Face palm* XD
Lol, it’s part of being American. XD We blow stuff up to celebrate our independence…I think we like blowing stuff up, lol. xD
But the one to one conversations are priceless!
Glad you liked it!!! đ And yes, one to one convos are always so much fun to read (and write!) đ
Also, in that last one, I love the mildly creepy way you described Felix. *Shudder* ?
Well…that’s what I was going for! XD So I’m glad you love it. đ
Yes. Weâre coming for you XD FridaâŚ
Yes…yes, we are. XD
Lol Girl, you are so funny XD!
*does a dramatic bow, almost falling on my face* Why, thank you! XD
Youâre welcome!! (Yep, thatâs the one! ? Yeah, I can tell youâve had lots of practice :)!
That fanfic has come a lot further than I ever expected…xD And yes, practice makes better, I always say! đ
Yes!! Itâs so sweet, and helps to give them a deeper relationship :). Iâm glad you did!
I’m glad you like it!!! đ
Lol! That sounds like me and my family XD.
Lol. XDXDXDXDXD
Youâre so welcome!! yay!! Oh, is Leon WagnerâŚLeon? As in, Rikerâs enemy turned best friend?
Sure is! đ His full name is Leon Jedidiah Wagner, hehe. XD
I love this! I like how the brothers interact with each other, itâs so much fun to read! And good job keeping them distinct with personalities and everything, thatâs hard when you have a lot of characters! Keep it up, I want to read more!
Thank you soooo much!!!! <3333
December 1, 2022 at 5:29 pm #122850Anonymous
- Rank: Chosen One
- Total Posts: 8156
@arien. @mineralizedwritings. @elishavet-pidyon. @godlyfantasy12. @lightoverdarkness6. @madelyn. @anyone-else-I’m-forgetting-lol. XD
So…I present the next chapter, which was honestly really fun to write…lol.
Chapter 5
Jakob shoveled more of the dirt into a pile, wiping the sweat from his brows.
The dirt was hard, what with the lack of rain recently, it was almost clay.
Jakob had to almost shove the shovel completely into the dirt, but at least he was still getting his job done.
What was he helping build? He had no clue. But the thing he was worried about were his older brothers and his younger brothers, not what he was building. Whatever it was.
He watched as Leo, beside him, also shoveled.
He seemedâŚalright, but also looked like he was struggling.
âLeoâŚwhatâs wrong?â
âNothing. Iâm fine.â
Jakob nodded, knowing that was a lie, as his grip on the shovelâs handle tightened.
Fridaâs âlessonâ from last week had been more than just a lesson.
Leoâs bruises testified to that fact.
All of her lessons were that way.
Jakobâs knuckles turned white.
She would pay.
One day.
One day she would pay.
They all would.
Eighteen years.
And they would pay for every single day. Every single bruise and scar.
âJakobâŚrelease your grip a littleâŚâ
âGet back to work! Schnell!â A uniformed guard yelled.
Jakob merely began to shovel again, the thoughts still running rampant, his heart still flaming.
One of the older Jewish men, with a black hat on his hair and payot running down the sides of his head, moved slowly, barely even picking up even a handful of dirt with each shovelful.
The guard yelled at him and marched over, cudgel in hand, his yells turning into screams.
He raised the cudgel, and Jakobâs grip tightened.
Heâd very often seen a hand raised.
Before he even knew what he was doing, he had the shovel raised and was heading for the guard.
âJakob, no! Donât!â
Leo suddenly grabbed his arm, tight, causing Jakob to drop the shovel.
It hit the ground, hard.
But the guard was too busy yelling to pay attention.
He blinked and faced his oldest brother. âLeoâŚ?â
Leoâs fingers dug into his arms, but not too hard, and only then did Jakob realize what he had almost done.
ââŚI was going to kill him.â
Leo nodded, letting go of his arm. âI saw that.â
âI sawâŚwellâŚâ
Leo nodded, eyes softening with concern. âI knowâŚI know what you sawâŚI did too.â
Jakob picked his shovel back up, and they both began shoveling, as the guard marched away, the old man in tow.
Jakobâs blood boiled, but he knew he couldnât do anything.
âShe wouldnât have wanted this for us, you knowâŚâ He whispered softly.
Leo looked at him with a raised eyebrow, confusion on his face, before he slowly closed his eyes. ââŚIâm sureâŚâ
âHey, Leo, you can talk about itâŚin fact, Wolfgang used to love your storiesâŚReuben did tooâŚall of us didâŚwe canât remember her as well as you doâŚand we loved all of the storiesâŚâ
Leo shook his head, opening his eyes. âJakob, I-IâŚI canâtâŚnot anymoreâŚâ
Their brown eyes met.
Leo had once been the optimistic one. The hopeful one. The one who always looked at the glass half-full. The one who always saw the good in people.
But all of that had been stripped away.
Jakobâs fists clenched again, and he forced the shovel, hard, into the dirt.
Frida would pay for hurting his brothers.
He would make sure of it.
~*~
On hands and knees, Reuben scrubbed at the street, as the sun beat down onto his head and back.
Cleaning the streetâŚwhat was the point of it?
But if Reuben had learned anything in the twenty years of his existence, it was that it was better to stay silent.
Donât ask questions.
Donât attract attention to yourself.
Give them no excuse to hurt you.
Reuben shoved away the memories that threatened to rise, instead focusing his attention on his younger brother, who scrubbed the street beside him, humming a quiet song under his breath.
Reuben couldnât stop the smile that spread up his face.
Wolfgang was so caringâŚcarefreeâŚhopeful.
And Reuben hoped he stayed that way forever.
Wolfgang didnât seem bothered at all about having to scrub the streets.
âHey, Wolfgang, what are you hummingâŚ?â Reuben asked softly, only speaking after he made sure a soldier guard wasnât close by.
Wolfgang turned to face him and smiled warmly. âOh, it was a song Joshua sang to me. Iâm not sure what all of it means, but I like the sound of it, so Iâve been humming it to pass time.â
Reuben smiled and nodded. âIt sounds nice.â
Wolfgangâs eyes lit up. âOh! I can teach it to you laterâŚit doesnât have a lot of lyrics, but itâs really pretty.â
Reuben nodded. âIâd like that. And maybe I can show you how to paint a tree.â
Wolfgangâs eyes widened. âReally!? Iâd love that!â
Reuben smiled. âOf course. Weâll do it tonightâŚhowâs that sound?â
His younger brother nodded enthusiastically. âIâd love to!â
Reuben turned back to his scrubbing, but slowly, he realized Wolfgang hadnât gone back to scrubbing.
ââŚReubenâŚ?â
Reuben scrubbed the street more. âYeah, Wolfgang?â
ââŚDo you remember those stories and songs Leo used to tell us aboutâŚ?â
âYeahâŚyeahâŚI think soâŚâ
Leo hadnât told one in around ten years.
But Reuben had never forgotten them.
ââŚWhy hasnât he told one in a long timeâŚ?  Itâs beenâŚa long time.â
ââŚI-I donât know WolfgangâŚmaybe he doesnât like themâŚ?â
âBut he loved the stories and songsâŚhe used to love telling themâŚand all of us loved themâŚwhy did Leo stop?â
Reuben shrugged.
He didnât know.
But even though he had never said anything, he wondered the same.
Reuben shook his head. âI donât have any idea why, WolfgangâŚonly Leo does.â
Wolfgang nodded and lapsed into silence.
Reuben scrubbed for a few more minutes when he heard his brotherâs voice again. ââŚI donât remember her, ReubenâŚyou knowâŚour real MuttiâŚwho Leoâs stories were about and who the songs came fromâŚâ
Reuben slowly nodded. âMe neither, WolfgangâŚâ
He remembered a smiling face.
A soft voice.
A lullaby.
But that was it.
And all of those things were fadedâŚfogy.
ââŚI was only two when she leftâŚâ
Wolfgang nodded, still scrubbing the street. âI was a baby.â
Reuben nodded in agreement. âYou were.â
âBut Leo was tenâŚso he remembers herâŚso why isnât he telling the stories anymore?â
Reuben bit his lip, thinking. Like Wolfgang, he didnât know nor understand. But suddenly, a small idea dawned on him, and he gave Wolfgang a small, faint, soft smile. ââŚIt might be hard for himâŚâ
Wolfgang nodded but bit his lip. ââŚReubenâŚwhy did she leave?â
Reuben blinked. Now that, he hadnât been expecting.
âYou know she and father separatedâŚâ
Wolfgang slowly nodded, biting his lip. âYeahâŚI meanâŚI know thatâŚcause you all told meâŚbutâŚwhy?â
âIâve often wondered the same thing, WolfgangâŚbutâŚI donât knowâŚI reallyâŚdonât.â
âDid she love us, Reuben?â Wolfgang suddenly asked, his bright blue eyes hoping, wanting to believe.
Reubenâs eyes slightly itched, and he stopped the tears from falling. âYes, Wolfgang, she did. Iâm sure of it Remember Leoâs storiesâŚ? She loved us with everything she hadâŚâ
Wolfgang bit his lip. ââŚBut she leftâŚ?â
Reuben shrugged. âI donât know why she left, WolfgangâŚI reallyâŚdonât. All I know is she didâŚeighteen years agoâŚbut because of Leoâs storiesâŚI also know that she loved us.â
ââŚDo you think sheâs still out there, ReubenâŚlooking for us?â
Reuben smiled softly and squeezed his younger brotherâs shoulder, even though he doubted that what Wolfgang said was true. âIâm sure she is.â
December 1, 2022 at 5:37 pm #122854@freedomwriter76
Ok Ok I didnt cry… ? but like I could feel the water in the back of my eyes a little.
That was so sad!
The ending scene was really sweet. love this!
I feel like Wolfgang’s happy soul needs to be protected ?.
"Past or future... let them be."
December 1, 2022 at 6:19 pm #122869Anonymous
- Rank: Chosen One
- Total Posts: 8156
Ok Ok I didnt cry⌠? but like I could feel the water in the back of my eyes a little.
That was so sad!
YOU DID!?!?!?!? AHHHHH!!!!!
As a writer, that makes me happy. As a friend, that makes me sad, lol. XDXDXDXDMixed feelings!The ending scene was really sweet. love this!
THANK YOU!!! I had to end on a sweeter note!!! <333
I feel like Wolfgangâs happy soul needs to be protected ?.
Yessss!!! Let’s all band around Wolfgang and keep him safe from the monsters. Who’s with me!?!?!? XDXDXD
December 1, 2022 at 6:33 pm #122875@freedomwriter76
UUUGGGHH U. ARE. BREAKING. EVERY. PIECE. OF. MY. HEART! THESE HORRIBLE JOBS!! HORRIBLE FAMILIES?!?! WHY CANâT THEY JUST ESCAPE AND LIVE HAPPY TOGETHER SOMEWHERE AND UUUUGGGGHHHHHHHH *flops dramatically onto sofa*
btw itâs reaaally good but UUUUGGGHHHH
#IfMarcelDiesIRiot
#ProtectMarcel
#ProtectSebDecember 1, 2022 at 6:49 pm #122878@freedomwriter76
Yessss!!! Letâs all band around Wolfgang and keep him safe from the monsters. Whoâs with me!?!?!? XDXDXD
EXCEPT IK WHAT HAPPENS TO HIM ? unless you changed thatâŚ.
Donât worry Iâm keeping my mouth shutâŚbutâŚ
???????
#IfMarcelDiesIRiot
#ProtectMarcel
#ProtectSebDecember 1, 2022 at 7:18 pm #122883@freedomwriter76
YesâŚyes, we are. XD
I think we’ve said ‘Yes’ about 5 times each…XDD
*does a dramatic bow, almost falling on my face* Why, thank you! XD
*jumps up from my chair, clapping, but then slips and actually does fall on my face* You’re welcome!! We’re such great performers XDXDXD
That fanfic has come a lot further than I ever expectedâŚxD And yes, practice makes better, I always say! ?
Yes it has! Like 25 chapters, right? That’s awesome! Yes! Such wise words. XD
Iâm glad you like it!!! ?
đ YES!!
Lol. XDXDXDXDXD
Yep! XDD
Sure is! ? His full name is Leon Jedidiah Wagner, hehe. XD
Yay!! Ooh, i love that name!
#HugRikerSquad
December 1, 2022 at 7:37 pm #122891@freedomwriter76
Wait, how many WIPs do you have??!!
Just kidding…
I’m enjoying this a lot. But I have a question, how old are they? You probably said already on one of your fanfic topics but I didn’t catch that.
He must increase, but I must decrease.
December 1, 2022 at 7:42 pm #122892@freedomwriter76
I love Leon’s full name! I have a 2 year old angel of a second cousin whose name is Jedidiah Casper. His middle name is after Corrie Ten Boom’s beloved father. They call him Jed for short and he’s adorable- silky, golden curls; dark, starry eyes; and the sweetest, lovable personality.
Whoops. This was supposed to be about LEON! đ
He must increase, but I must decrease.
December 1, 2022 at 10:03 pm #122921@freedomwriter76
AHHHH! I love it!
So, the normal human being part of me is horrified, but the history nerd author? She grinned through most of those chapters whispering “she got it right. She got it right!”
Although I am still a tad bit confused over their whole ‘still living in the same house as their father even though their Jews…’. this isn’t far into WWII, is it?
A cup of tea is cheaper than therapy.
December 2, 2022 at 8:12 am #122927Anonymous
- Rank: Chosen One
- Total Posts: 8156
UUUGGGHH U. ARE. BREAKING. EVERY. PIECE. OF. MY. HEART! THESE HORRIBLE JOBS!! HORRIBLE FAMILIES?!?! WHY CANâT THEY JUST ESCAPE AND LIVE HAPPY TOGETHER SOMEWHERE AND UUUUGGGGHHHHHHHH *flops dramatically onto sofa*
btw itâs reaaally good but UUUUGGGHHHH
Thank you!!! I know, I know…XD
EXCEPT IK WHAT HAPPENS TO HIM ? unless you changed thatâŚ.
Donât worry Iâm keeping my mouth shutâŚbutâŚ
???????
Shhhhh…that’s a secret….XD And so far, no, I haven’t changed it, heh.
Wait, how many WIPs do you have??!!
Just kiddingâŚ
Iâm enjoying this a lot. But I have a question, how old are they? You probably said already on one of your fanfic topics but I didnât catch that.
A lot, lol. XD
Thank you!!!
Okay, so, Wolfgang is 18, Reuben is 20, Jakob is 24, Joshua is 25, and Leo is 28. Their ages will be revealed, just kinda slowly. But I have already established the order, so at least I have that! XD
I love Leonâs full name! I have a 2 year old angel of a second cousin whose name is Jedidiah Casper. His middle name is after Corrie Ten Boomâs beloved father. They call him Jed for short and heâs adorable- silky, golden curls; dark, starry eyes; and the sweetest, lovable personality.
Whoops. This was supposed to be about LEON! ?
That is sooo cool and adorable!!!! <3333
I think weâve said âYesâ about 5 times eachâŚXDD
Lol. XD
*jumps up from my chair, clapping, but then slips and actually does fall on my face* Youâre welcome!! Weâre such great performers XDXDXD
Spectacular performers. XD
Yay!! Ooh, i love that name!
Thank you!!! I love it too!! <333
AHHHH! I love it!
AHHH!!!! THANK YOU!!!!! <3333
So, the normal human being part of me is horrified, but the history nerd author? She grinned through most of those chapters whispering âshe got it right. She got it right!â
Lol, yess….so glad I get the History Nerd author stamp of approval, lol. XD I always have to have the History in there, even not well known History. đ
Although I am still a tad bit confused over their whole âstill living in the same house as their father even though their JewsâŚâ. this isnât far into WWII, is it?
It is…and I’ve been thinking about the same question.
I’m thinking it’s because, at least that’s what I’m doing right now, their father has high standings within the Military, Government, and the Community, so he’s kept them at his house to “keep an eye on them”…but he may change his mind as the story goes on, so…we’ll see. đ
Felix is a very high-ranking SS officer, and possibly even knows Heinrich Himmler personally, heh. đ
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
