Cloaked Mystery

@esther-c

Awesome! This looks like it will be a lot of fun.

For the ties, we could just rerun them through eliminating the other options. That way the people whose choices lost will decide between the tied options.

Wingfeather Saga and Mistborn trilogy tied on this question. I’m not sure if we’ll be able to fit both vibes in, but you’ll have to…

[Read more]

@rae

Okay. I’ve never heard of those before.

@rae

That makes sense. I do think it would be better to either have more sci-fi elements or not mention them at all. As it is, it’s just enough to be confusing. I would imagine that if you did write this into a novella, it would fix the problem, since you would have more time for it to become clear.

Is a zip a real thing or is it an instance o…[Read more]

@rae

Very nice, and I think it would work very well as a novella! The only thing I’m confused about is that it apparently takes place in a sci-fi world (since you mentioned other planets), but the setting seemed to be normal.

🤣🤣

@esther-c

That would have made it clearer (especially since it was the only one like that…I hope) but it was also my fault for not reading the directions.

@esther-c @loopylin

I think that’s something that we should decide once we have the characters mostly fleshed out.

Resubmitted. I’m not sure if you’ll get two submissions from me, but if you do, just ignore the one where I didn’t select 3rd vs. first person.

Ah, sorry, didn’t see that we were supposed to pick one of each. Now I’ve got to resubmit.

@esther-c

Completed. Can’t wait to see how it comes out!

Quick question/suggestion: I’m assuming dual POV and single POV is about whether we have both characters be viewpoint characters or not. Maybe that should be a separate question from 1st/3rd person POV, because we could technically have a 1st person dual POV or a 3rd person dual POV, or…[Read more]

@highscribeofaetherium

I don’t think that’s necessarily true. Especially if we intentionally keep HF as the main sub genre. Steampunk is actually more of a sci-fi genre than fantasy. Regardless, I don’t think we would get enough votes for that to happen.

(Also, note that 2 pages back, there were a few votes for AF and one for HF from people that didn’t revote after we implemented the ranking system. It wouldn’t have changed the outcome though, I don’t think.)

@esther-c

Sounds good!

So high fantasy it is!! This will be interesting… 😏 (Although I reeeally wanted steampunk to win… XD)

I also would have been interested in doing steampunk, but I just went with what I’m most familiar with, which is HF.

We could vote on adding a second sub-genre. (Although I’m not sure if HF is compatible with UF.) No seco…[Read more]

@theducktator

I don’t think everyone has replied since we changed to the ranking system, but just counting those, it looks like high fantasy is the runaway winner.

@highscribeofaetherium

You should be able to export as a PNG and email/text it to yourself.

I agree with @rae. It’s a normal cycle. There have been ice ages for crying out loud! I’m not going to say it’s not a problem at all—I’m not well read on this subject—but at this point I don’t think we have to worry about it.

I don’t believe it. It…it’s working!

@theducktator

That second one is beautiful. 🤣

@rae @theshadow @grcr

Thank you!

@loopylin

I’m sure you can change your vote.