The Narrow Path Trilogy Book I: The Cost

Home Page › Forums › Fiction Writing › Critiques › Novel Critique Requests › The Narrow Path Trilogy Book I: The Cost

Viewing 7 posts - 691 through 697 (of 697 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #197532
    Keilah H.
    @keilah-h
      • Rank: Chosen One
      • Total Posts: 7143

      @linus-smallprint I think that works!

      Gerald handled that. You don’t question Gerald. (if you know you know)

      #197560
      Ellette Giselle
      @ellette-giselle
        • Rank: Chosen One
        • Total Posts: 5095

        @linus-smallprint

        I like this much better. I feel more comfortable, but it also plays into the allegory style better. (At least  in my opinion)

        my only suggestion (besides fine combing because there were a few typos) is old be this paragraph.

        I do not know what Alan thought as he used the spell, so instead of telling you that, let’s say he instead focused on the lyen guards. He tried to block out the noise of their words, imagining grunts and roars in their place. (I know magic does not work this way, or else wizards could do anything they put their mind to.) Suddenly, the world around him blurred and faded away.

        it just feels a little odd, maybe even out of place. I would chop it up a little so that it reads more like this:

         

        I do not know what Alan thought as he used the spell, and I won’t pretend to. All I know is that he focused on (or you could say “he looked at”)  the lyen guards. He tried to block out the noise of their words, and began to cast his spell. Suddenly, the world around him blurred and faded away.

        This feels more in keeping with the above paragraphs instead of trying to have an alternate sort of version. It also makes more sense to the reader and we get enough information as it is.

        HOWEVER if you like the other way better then go ahead. Again, this is your book and in the end, you’re the author. These are just my opinions.

         

        And those who were seen dancing were thought to be insane by those who couldn't hear the music

        #197607
        Linus Smallprint
        @linus-smallprint
          • Rank: Eccentric Mentor
          • Total Posts: 1303

          @keilah-h @ellette-giselle

          Thanks for the feedback! I thing I will go with this then.

          In regards to your suggestion, Ellette, I think I might go with something that. I noticed in those paragraphs, I had fallen back into the narration style I used in the first draft. (Awkward! Overly Defensive!) This is probably part of why it feels odd to you. The version you provided fits better with the style I am trying to achieve.

          Sometimes it is necessary to paint the sky black in order to see the stars.

          #197610
          Keilah H.
          @keilah-h
            • Rank: Chosen One
            • Total Posts: 7143

            @linus-smallprint you’re welcome! Looking forward to book 2!

            Gerald handled that. You don’t question Gerald. (if you know you know)

            #197612
            Ellette Giselle
            @ellette-giselle
              • Rank: Chosen One
              • Total Posts: 5095

              @linus-smallprint

              awesome! Glad I could be of help.

              I think we’re all a little defensive of our stuff. ?

              I remember when you kept criticizing Aaron I was crushed because he’s a lot like me and I felt like you were criticizing me and saying I was a cardboard cutout. It took a few weeks for me to separate myself from him and see your criticism as helpful!?

              (which I’m actually really grateful for it looking back. ☺️)

               

              And those who were seen dancing were thought to be insane by those who couldn't hear the music

              #199361
              Linus Smallprint
              @linus-smallprint
                • Rank: Eccentric Mentor
                • Total Posts: 1303

                @loopylin @theshadow

                Just so the two of you know, I will be taking down the link for the second draft of TNPT at the end of this month. If you cannot finish reading it in that time, don’t worry about it. I can recruit you again when I get to the third draft.

                Sometimes it is necessary to paint the sky black in order to see the stars.

                #199516
                TheShadow
                @theshadow
                  • Rank: Knight in Shining Armor
                  • Total Posts: 719

                  @linus-smallprint

                  Thanks for letting me know.

                  “He sure is a frog-walker, he heaves a big sigh
                  He only lacks wings for to be on the fly.”

                Viewing 7 posts - 691 through 697 (of 697 total)
                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                >