- This topic has 51 replies, 26 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 7 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Which one of the two? First or Third? Person, that is. First person or third person? I’ve been writing in first person for soooooo long, I can’t decide which to do. The story I’m working on seems like it would be written in third, because there are so many POV’s to do, but first person is more my speed.
I guess what I’m asking is for you all to just tell me which you prefer to read better, as a kind of poll thing. If you have any suggestions, tips or hints on either of the two, that would be greatly appreciated.
But mainly, I just want to know which you prefer.
Thanks!
-Dragon Snapper- 📎
@daeus @bluejay @kate-flournoy @emma-flournoy @leumeister @perfectfifths @winter-rose @overcomer @jess @writefury @corissa-maiden-of-praise @anne-of-lothlorien @alia @the-bean @mark-kamibaya @warrioroftherealm @Julia-r @his-instrument @Christi-eaton @ethryndal
Tag anyone I’ve missed.☀ ☀ ☀ ENFP ☀ ☀ ☀
First. I like reading books written in first person as it makes it more personal, more real.
@dragon-snapper@nataliemarie @hope @clairec @rolena-hatfield @anne-swiftblade @rebelutoinary
☀ ☀ ☀ ENFP ☀ ☀ ☀
My preference? I’m not totally sure, but I think I tend toward third person, particularly omnipotent.
Now from what you’re saying, it sounds to me like you’d do best with a deep third person story. It could be confusing to use first person for multiple POVs (though who know? Might be the next thing.) If you’re used to first though, you might have trouble with omnipotent. Really, if you write third person deep, the only difference between that and first person is the pronouns. You can still have the same level of intimacy with the characters.
🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢🐢
- Rank: Eccentric Mentor
- Total Posts: 1486
@dragon-snapper I write in deep third POV (though I tend to write first person in short stories). I don’t know what I like better. You could try third out in a short story if you are considering changing your project. @Daeus is right about deep third. It’s not that much different from first other than the pronouns.
And about multiple POVs in a first person book, I read a book where the MC was in first and the side characters were in third and it didn’t throw me off. There were only three POV’s though. Anyway, food for thought.I like to read 1st best, however, that could be because the things that I have read in 1st have been really well written all the way around. In writing… it depends on the project, I write in both.
I prefer third-person, reading and writing, though I’m not strictly a third-person-reader or writer. But it depends on who or what the story is focussing on whether you writer in first- or third-person, and what kind of a mood you want to set, because the different POVs do set different moods. With first-person, it gives you the chance to explore more the thoughts of your MC, but with third-person, you can explore multiple character in the same scene as well. It’s really up to you, ultimately. 🙂
Currently reading Les Miserables
This is a tough question. For reading, I don’t really have a preference unless I’m not content with the way it’s already written. Often, I see a lot of situations that are awkward if written in the wrong tense. But my biggest pet peeve when it comes to reading is when the author changes tenses every couple of paragraphs.
For writing, I’d say third person is easier unless I’m writing from my own personal perspective. Maybe I like third person because I’m used to writing formal essays, but I’ve found it’s more difficult to write for a character, especially if you are getting to know them as you write.
I’d say if you have a lot of characters, but enjoy first person and want to do separate points of view, try and stick with one person being first, and then have the chapters or paragraphs about the other characters in third.
Deep third person. I write sprawling epics with gazillions of characters, and deep third person works best for those kinds. If I was writing YA or something similar with only one MC, I’d probably choose first for a deep personal connection though.
I used to ONLY write third person, and I had no idea if it was omnipotent, or omnipresent, or whatever. Still don’t quite remember those. @Daeus what are those things?
But now I write mostly in first person. I like focusing on one person personally better, and it lets me put in weird thoughts that I probably wouldn’t if it was third person.
But you forgot one thing though. Second person. I really want to know if anyone here has ever written a second person something, even a short story. @Daeus @hope @writefury @emma-flournoy @kate-flournoy @bluejay @winter-rose @Mark-Kamibaya @his-instrument @dragon-snapper @anne-swiftblade @ethryndal @anne-brie @Rolena-Hatfield @corissa-maiden-of-praise @writefury @the-bean @overcomer @perfectfifths @warrioroftherealm @Julia-r @Christi-eaton @jess @alia @rebolutionary
ENFP - "One must be sane to think clearly, but one can think deeply and be quite insane."
I used to ONLY write third person, and I had no idea if it was omnipotent, or omnipresent, or whatever. Still don’t quite remember those. @Daeus what are those things?
But now I write mostly in first person. I like focusing on one person personally better, and it lets me put in weird thoughts that I probably wouldn’t if it was third person.
But you forgot one thing though. Second person. I really want to know if anyone here has ever written a second person something, even a short story. @Daeus @hope @writefury @emma-flournoy @kate-flournoy @bluejay @winter-rose @Mark-Kamibaya @his-instrument @dragon-snapper @anne-swiftblade @ethryndal @Rolena-Hatfield @corissa-maiden-of-praise @writefury @the-bean @overcomer @perfectfifths @warrioroftherealm @Julia-r @Christi-eaton @jess @alia
ENFP - "One must be sane to think clearly, but one can think deeply and be quite insane."
@kate-flournoy: What do you mean by deep third-person? How is that different to regular third-person?
Currently reading Les Miserables
@Anne-of-Lothlorien not me. I mean, I may have done it subconsciously in a few diary entries, but that’s about it. (My diary is a mess of gargantuan proportions from a literary standpoint. Don’t ask). 😛
@PerfectFifths good question. The difference between third person and deep third person is that deep third person actually delves into the thoughts of the characters, not just stays on the surface and monitors their actions.
@Anne-of-Lothorien Aha, second-person. That is when it’s “You do this” as opposed to “I did this” or “He did this”, right? I have written a Choose Your Own Adventure story for my friend once, and I used second-person, then I took it and turned it into first-person and started making it into a proper story, rather than a CYOA. But most CYOAs use second-person, since you’re the one the story is happening to, and you’re making the choices. 😀
Currently reading Les Miserables
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.